Relax. There may be less to this story than meets the eye, indicating exactly why you don't make changes based on a single study.
This study has its share of weaknesses, such as studying a very small number of rats -- as few as eight in some of the groups. It also uses saccharine, instead of a sugar substitute with a taste closer to that of sugar. There are a number of other flaws as well -- enough to prevent drawing real conclusions from the results.
What's more, these results contrast with other studies showing that rats do compensate for calories pretty well when there is no perceptible taste difference.
I actually did one such study years ago as a lowly graduate student. I was all excited about being able to use aspartame (Nutrasweet) before it was released to consumers. We used normal-weight rats and rats that were fattened up with high-calorie, fatty, sugary food, to mimic how many people become overweight. Then we placed them on liquid diets -- sweetened with sugar and sweetened with aspartame. The aspartame liquids contained either 20 percent or 40 percent fewer calories.
When the rats got the liquid with 20 percent fewer calories, they just drank more of it and maintained their weight -- whether they were overweight rats or normal weight rats. When they got the liquid with 40 percent fewer calories, they couldn't eat enough to maintain their weight and they all lost weight.
Weight Loss 101
Before we go on, remember that there are two things almost no one disputes:
Now let's get to the bigger issue for consumers. This study and any similar study, including mine, only explains obesity from a physiological and metabolic standpoint. That might be okay if we only ate because of internal factors. That is, if we "listened to our body instead of our heads," and all that common-sense stuff. Of course, if we did that, we would have no obesity problem.
Unfortunately, we're not rats. We're humans, and factors such as emotions, the environment, stress, advertising, group pressure, you name it, often affect what, why, and how much we eat, and these factors can't be measured very well in rats.
Tools of the Weight-Loss Trade
Any sugar substitute in your diet should be seen only as a tool. Like any tool, you can use it wisely, or not.
Unfortunately, sugar substitutes are increasingly being asked to do a job for which they were never intended. They will not "make" you lose weight. They will only help you to stick to a low-calorie or maintenance diet a little more comfortably.
If you use them to cut calories in a drink, only to overeat somewhere else in your diet, you're going to gain weight, but not because you used a sugar substitute, but because you overate. If you had eaten more wisely elsewhere, and used the diet drink to allow you have a sweeter liquid than plain water, you'd have been ahead of the game by 150 calories or so.
Now, one could argue that such is the problem with sugar substitutes: they lure you into a false sense of caloric security. Wrong. The burden of weight management was never supposed to be dumped on the back of a sugar substitute. It takes effort, and we need to come to grips with that.
Sugar substitutes can be one step on the pathway to a healthier weight, but if it's the only step, you won't reach your goal. Of course, sugar substitutes are not a required tool of the job, just an option. Keep to drinking plain water or seltzer and you're fine, too.
Taste Bud Trappings
From a food science standpoint, drinks with sugar substitutes are little more than no-calorie flavored water, with or without fizz. However, some question whether constantly drinking sweet beverages will "dumb down" our taste buds, so that we'll lose the desire for plainer tasting beverages like water or low-fat milk.
As a nutritionist, I have an additional concern that people who overconsume sweet beverages (either the regular kind or the diet kind) will get so used to super-sweet tastes, that they'll dismiss the natural sweetness present in healthful foods like fresh fruit, so that eating an apple, for example, just tastes too plain. One patient of mine complained that fresh fruit seemed "totally boring." Another patient used to eat fruit only if it was sprinkled with sugar. Using a sugar substitute helped him cut some calories, but he's left with the same sweet tooth.
If you find yourself upping the number of sweet drinks you take each day, or increasing the number of packets of sweetener in your coffee, and you also notice you're eating more sweets -- say a brownie with your afternoon coffee, instead of a banana, you may also notice it's become harder to lose weight or keep off extra weight. That's not because of the increased sweeteners, but because you're eating more calories overall
If this has happened to you, don't sweat it. Just consider it a wake-up call to get back to basics. Here are some tips to use the sweetener tools more wisely: