Here are a few samples of their responses:
A woman named Jennifer said, "A half-eaten bag of pink and red M&M's. He said he got hungry on the way home."
Wendy said, "one of those razors that yanks the hair out by the roots," while Kaitlyn said she got an unsigned card because her man wanted to be able to reuse it the next year.
Sharon reported getting a Dustbuster vacuum cleaner.
And last but certainly not least, Brandy said she got lice. "He bought me a hat at a secondhand store, and three days later, our whole house was infected," she wrote.
One final tip: Check the card. A few readers said they had received gifts with another woman's name on them.