Brooks Shoe Service, located at 29 East Madison Street, closed two weeks ago without returning luxury items worth thousands of dollars.
Former customer Jacquie Amacher said she lost a $2,000 handbag.
Owner Mike Morelli spoke to ABC7 Friday night and did not deny that he threw away some customers' belongings. Morelli said customers were given fair warning.
Brooks Shoe Service had been in business for nearly 30 years.