On Monday, a Chicago man - identified as Samuel Dellano - was arrested in connection with the incident that occurred on June 29 at St. Martha's Church.
Dellano and another woman are accused of stealing two religious artifacts, breaking another and taking money from donation boxes
The woman was not in custody Monday night, police said.
Dellano was taken into custody after he was spotted near Harlem and Dempster. He allegedly had the same tool that he used to pilfer money from the donation boxes. He was charged with burglary and possession of burglary tools.