Investigators arrested Jonatan Luna-Carrasco on Saturday.
According to the Lake County Sheriff's Office, he pulled alongside two women as they were driving on Route 41 in Wadsworth.
Investigators said Luna-Carrasco told the women they had a flat tire and they pulled over.
When the victim got into Luna-Carasco's SUV to stay warm, he drove off with her inside. She was able to jump out in Gurnee.
Lake County Sheriff's Deputy Chief Chris Covelli said investigators believe Luna-Carrasco has done this before.
Luna-Carrasco was in court on Monday afternoon for a detention hearing and will remain in custody.