There was actually research done about it just published in Biology Letters.
Scientists believe that outline is not of a rat - but more likely, a squirrel.
Using the measurements of the imprint, they say the impression resembles a squirrel - stocky and semi-aquatic with webbed feet.
RELATED: Chicago Rat Hole: Couple gets married at rat-shaped imprint in Roscoe Village
The Chicago Rat Hole was located near Roscoe Street and Damen Avenue before it was removed.