The girl was abducted, held against her will and beaten over a two-day period.
She was able to escape and provide information to the officers who then arrested her alleged 17-year-old kidnapper.
He has now been charged with multiple offenses.
Nancy Guthrie live updates: Gloves among 'several items of evidence' recovered
"The victim's parents also expressed their gratitude, praising the officers for their empathy," said Art Hannus, executive director of the Chicago Police Memorial Foundation.
The officers were named the February Officer of the Month award recipients.
It was Hannus' first event as executive director.
He praised longtime leader Phil Cline, who recently retired.
INTERACTIVE SAFETY TRACKER | Track crime and safety in your neighborhood