Pillow Talk: Cheating on Craigslist

CHICAGO -- Monday's Pillow Talk question got a huge reaction from our live studio audience. It comes from "Ms. D" in Chicago. She writes:

"I met my boyfriend on Craigslist five years ago. He's a kind, generous and romantic person. However I've never fully trusted him, partly because of the way we met. I noticed him on CL one day and he explained that he was looking for a computer. When he left, I checked. He's been less than forthcoming. I set up a 'sting' ad and he responded to it. He even sent his picture and phone number. Needless to say, I was flabbergasted! Guess what? I did it again (under a different name) and he responded again! Online, he claims to be a widow, saying he hasn't been in a relationship in three years. What??? ...Quite frankly, I've become addicted to these stings... I want to set him up and have him meet me at Starbucks. What do you think?"

Val, Ryan, Ji and Roe Conn weigh in on the question.

Do you have your own "Pillow Talk" question? Got a problem we can solve? Need relationship advice? Just click on THIS LINK and send it to us. You could win yourself a Coconut Bliss Pillow from our friends at Mattress Firm.