Judge denies motion to throw out case against 3 Chicago cops accused in Laquan McDonald shooting cover-up

Evelyn Holmes Image
Wednesday, December 5, 2018
Trial continues for 3 CPD officers accused of police shooting cover-up
The trial of three Chicago police officers continued on Tuesday.

CHICAGO (WLS) -- A Cook County judge denied Tuesday a request from defense attorneys to throw out the case against three Chicago police officers accused of covering up what happened the night Jason Van Dyke fatally shot Laquan McDonald.

Also on Tuesday, the fourth day of the bench trial, the prosecution rested their case after the judge ruled in their favor to enter key evidence - email exchanges between Chicago Police Department supervisors.

RELATED: Jason Van Dyke Verdict: Chicago officer found guilty in Laquan McDonald shooting trial

Some of the emails were read aloud in court, and the prosecutor suggests that the officers' superiors wanted to protect former officer Jason Van Dyke, who shot McDonald.

The defense argued that the email exchanges are not proof of a conspiracy.

Laquan McDonald

The decision could help the prosecution establish its theory that the cops maintained a police code of silence and conspired to cover up the truth.

In one email an officer writes, "Any luck making the case go away?"

Other emails between officers, including some not charged, could be damaging as well. The state read one of the more explosive emails into evidence.

The bench trial started a week ago against David March and Joseph Walsh, both retired, and Thomas Gaffney, who is suspended without pay.

VIDEOS: Trial of 3 CPD officers accused of cover-up in Laquan McDonald shooting (1 of 6)

The trial comes after Van Dyke, a now-former Chicago police officer, was found guilty of second degree murder in the shooting death of Laquan McDonald in October 2014.

Prosecutors said the men coordinated their stories and made false police reports in the hours after Van Dyke fired 16 shots, killing McDonald.

Last week, Chicago police Officer Dora Fontaine, who was granted immunity for being the prosecution's key witness, testified that she witnessed the shooting, and said that details in reports that were attributed to her not accurate, including the detail that Van Dyke was the victim of assault.

Civilian Jose Torres, who witnessed the shooting, also testified that officers told him and another motorist to leave the scene without taking their statements or information.

RELATED: CPD Officer Dora Fontaine testifies against 3 cops accused of cover-up in Laquan McDonald shooting

The trial resumes at 11:30 a.m. Thursday.