Travis McMichael, his father Greg McMichael and neighbor William "Roddie" Bryan were all convicted in the fatal shooting after jurors deliberated for about 10 hours. The men face minimum sentences of life in prison. It is up to the judge to decide whether that comes with or without the possibility of parole.
VIDEO: Verdicts are read for 3 men on trial for death of Ahmaud Arbery
All 3 men charged in Arbery's death convicted of murder
While those guilty verdicts were rendered a thousand miles away, but many in Chicago, many say the jury's decision hits close to home.
"Today was a small victory... But make no mistake, we have a long way to go for racial justice," said Steven Dornbusch with Chicago Alliance Against Racist and Political Repression.
"We just can't look at this in a vacuum because we get a guilty verdict. We expect a guilty verdict when the facts speak for itself," added Troy Gaston, with Black Lives Matter.
A coalition of activists praising the jury's verdicts Wednesday night, while asking why it took months to bring charges against the defendants.
"There is a taste of victory here, but it would not have happened if people hadn't poured into the streets," said Dee Williams, with Revolution Club Chicago.
"[Arbery] was killed for no reason other than the color of his skin, and regardless of the accountability that his killers now face-that fact speaks volumes about how far we have yet to go," Mayor Lori Lightfoot said in a statement.
The Reverend Jesse Jackson, who attended part of the trial in Georgia, said in the end, the nearly all-White jury did not want its community to harbor killers. He added that it gives him some measure of hope that jurors came to this decision.
"I left convinced that the prosecution was arguing a substantial case, lots of documentation," he said at Rainbow Push Coalition Headquarters. "The jury, I got the impression, was going to be very fair."
WATCH: Rev. Jesse Jackson reacts to verdict
Rev. Jesse Jackson reacts to Ahmaud Arbery verdict
For some in the Black community, there was concern about the racial makeup of the jury and how it could impact the outcome of the trial. There was only one Black juror and the rest were white.
"I am appreciative of good people who are tired of an abusive system made the right decision," said Kim L. Dulaney, DuSable Museum Director of Education & Programs.
Amika Tendaji heads Black Lives Matter Chicago. She was one many across the country outraged by this case and believe the men targeted Arbery because of his race.
RELATED: Kyle Rittenhouse, Ahmaud Arbery cases saw similar claims of self-defense, far different outcomes
Although she is pleased with the guilty verdict, she said she's not convinced that this is a sign of change in the criminal justice system.
"History has these one-offs, where the system will sacrifice a few of its own to keep us believing that things have shifted and we're OK to keep us complacent," she said.
All 3 men charged in Arbery's death convicted of murder
Tendaji said it's important for her organizations and others to continue fighting for change.
"I don't feel like my sons are any safer," she added.
Activists in Chicago said those verdicts in Georgia offer lessons here.
"I think the same lesson that we took from Laquan McDonald: it does not happen without people power in the streets," said Jay Becker with RefuseFascism.org.
The Associated Press contributed to this article.