That murder led to a consent decree mandating police reforms, but progress has been spotty, says one attorney who help craft the consent decree and now works for a law and policy center.
SEE ALSO | Protests held outside home of Gov. Pritzker, who says he's 'disappointed' by Van Dyke release
"Chicago has made very slow progress in implementing the terms of the consent decree," said Shareese Pryor, Dir. Police Accountability, BPI Chicago.
"Although there has been, you know, discernible progress in some discrete areas, we have thus far failed and our institutions have failed to really rise to that challenge," said Jamie Kalven, who founded the Invisible Institute, and was the investigative journalist who broke the Laquan McDonald story. He blames the lack of progress on police reform on a failure of political leadership.
SEE ALSO | 'Don't let this man out:' Laquan McDonald's grandmother calls for Jason Van Dyke to stay in prison
Mayor Lori Lightfoot brushed off the criticism while defending her police superintendent.
"We are not where we want to be when it comes to police reform and accountability, but we are further along in two plus years of doing this work, than any other city that has been under consent decree," Lightfoot said.
"There are way too many steps left to go to ensure that we don't see another Laquan McDonald," Pryor said.
RELATED | Activists continue fight for federal civil rights charges against Jason Van Dyke ahead of release
While the mayor was not happy with Van Dyke's sentence, she and her critics agree on the importance of the verdict.
"Jason Van Dyke was the first police officer in 50 years who was convicted of committing a crime while on duty," Lightfoot said.
"The verdict is far more important than the sentence, and I'm not sure we'd be in a different place as a city right now if Jason Van Dyke had gotten 12 years or 20 years," Kalven said.
Critics contend the police department is reluctant to embrace the changes needed to bring about real reform. While the mayor concedes it is hard to change the status quo, she says the city is moving in the right direction.