The landlord claims Henyard and Kamal Woods owe nearly $10,000 in unpaid rent and other costs.
A judge ruled on Monday that Henyard's name was not properly signed on the lease. However, Woods owes the landlord more than $7,000.
The judge also ruled that Henyard's Social Security number was willfully exposed in documents.
Henyard is entitled to $1,000 from the landlord to offset the costs of an ID protection service. The landlord also has to pay Henyard $500 in attorney fees.
SEE ALSO | Dolton Mayor Tiffany Henyard facing eviction from home, court documents show
READ MORE | Cook County sheriff's deputies trying to serve Dolton Mayor Tiffany Henyard with eviction papers