'American Horror Story' Season 13 conjures up 'Love Story' star Paul Anthony Kelly

NEW YORK -- FX's hit show "American Horror Story" conjures up a new cast member, "Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette" star Paul Anthony Kelly!

The exciting announcement was made at the 2026 Disney Upfront Presentation in New York City. Before the *supreme* surprise, Kelly spoke with On The Red Carpet and teased being in a future Ryan Murphy project. "I sure hope so. Maybe someday!," the actor shared.

Also joining the Season 13 cast are familiar witches, Billie Lourd ("American Horror Story: Apocalypse") and Gabourey Sidibe ("American Horror Story: Coven").

"The magic you see, it's seconds. But for us on set, the last time I worked we spent all day doing one scene. 16 hours doing one single scene," Sidibe revealed to On The Red Carpet about filming scenes with magic.

Lourd explained, "We did one scene over this week, two days. One scene!"

Casting spells in the next installment includes returning actors Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Angela Bassett and Emma Roberts.

Watch the interview above to find why Lourd and Sidibe want Golden Globe winner Teyana Taylor to join the dark arts with them.

Catch up on all 12 seasons of "American Horror Story," streaming now on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+.

Season 13 of the legendary anthology series will be scaring screens this fall to FX and Hulu.

The Walt Disney Company is the parent company of FX, Hulu, Disney+ and this ABC station.