Family claims Texas woman died from Legionnaires' disease contracted at Northwestern Memorial Hospital

Mark Rivera Image
Saturday, October 19, 2019
Family claims Texas woman died from Legionnaires' disease contracted at Northwestern Memorial Hospital
A family is suing Northwestern Memorial Hospital over the death of a Texas woman who they say contracted Legionnaires' disease from another patient at the Chicago medical center.

CHICAGO (WLS) -- A family is suing Northwestern Memorial Hospital over the death of a Texas woman who they say contracted Legionnaires' disease from another patient at the Chicago medical center.

The woman's family is accusing the hospital of negligence and wrongful death.

They claimed she contracted Legionnaires' from another person housed on the same floor of the hospital, calling her death preventable.

"We had many plans, we had hobbies," said Gibran Ruiz through tears.

Ruiz is still in mourning, recounting the life he and his wife Carol wanted before she died.

"I still wake up some days in complete disbelief that this happened," he said.

According to the Ruiz family attorney, 35-year-old Carol Ruiz was admitted to Northwestern Memorial Hospital on October 25, 2017, for a clinical trial to help patients with multiple sclerosis.

Her immune system was suppressed as part of treatment.

Less than a month later, she was dead after contracting Legionnaires' disease.

"While Carol was a patient at Northwestern, she was exposed to contaminated water," said attorney Thomas R. Mulroy III of Salvi, Schostok & Prichard.

The victim's daughter, Melanie Cosme, is also involved in the lawsuit.

"I'm a senior in college, and I wish that she could have seen me graduate," Cosme said.

Attorney Thomas Mulroy said Northwestern Hospital housed Ruiz - with a compromised immune system - on an improper floor.

Five months earlier, another person contracted Legionnaires. The Illinois Department of Public Health connected both cases late in 2017.

Northwestern Memorial Hospital declined to comment due to pending litigation.

According to an email from the Chicago Department of Public Health provided by Mulroy, Legionella bacteria was found in the sink of Ruiz's room at Northwestern Hospital. In the email, an official states water temperatures and copper ion levels were too low. Water temperatures and ion levels can help prevent Legionella bacteria from growing.

Gibran Ruiz said he wants answers.

"We'd like to know why, we'd like to know more about what actually happened and not silence, because that says nothing," Ruiz said.

The Illinois Department of Public Health is reporting a steady increase in Legionnaires' disease cases reported in the state over the past 10 years:

2018 = 509

2017 = 332

2016 = 318

2015 = 315

2014 = 249

2013 = 299

2012 = 226

2011 = 151

2010 = 149

2009 = 134