Massachusetts mom charged with strangling 3 kids to death planned their killings, prosecutors say

ABCNews logo
Tuesday, February 7, 2023
Lindsay Clancy: Massachusetts mother accused of killing her 3 children
A Massachusetts mother is accused of killing her 3 children before harming herself, officials say.

PLYMOUTH, Mass. -- A Massachusetts woman charged with strangling her three young children to death last month planned the killings, prosecutors argued on Tuesday, disclosing new details about the actions of the woman, Lindsay Clancy, on the day of the incident.

Prosecutors, trying to prove that Clancy was not mentally compromised on Jan. 24, the day of the deaths, described in court a day that suggested nothing out of the ordinary. She took a child to the pediatrician's office and built a snowman with her kids in their backyard.

SEE ALSO | Mother accused of killing her 3 kids was overmedicated, lacks criminal responsibility, attorney says

Late that afternoon, according to prosecutors, Clancy, who appeared in court Tuesday via Zoom from her hospital bed, searched on Apple Maps the time it would take to drive to and from a restaurant in an adjacent town. She then called the restaurant to place a pick-up order before asking her husband, Patrick, to drive to get the meal.

The restaurant, in Plymouth, was further from the family's Duxbury home than where they normally ordered take-out from, said Jennifer Sprague, the Plymouth County assistant district attorney, who added that Clancy sounded mentally intact when placing order.

"The hostess who took the call said there was nothing out of the ordinary about this call. Her voice was not slurred or impaired in any way," Sprague said.

Shortly after her husband left, Clancy texted him to ask him to buy medication at CVS on the way to the restaurant. While there, he called Clancy to clarify which medicine to get - a phone call Patrick Clancy told prosecutors was "completely normal," though he noted that his wife "seemed like she was in the middle of something."

Patrick Clancy described to prosecutors returning home to his wife on the ground in the backyard, with cuts on her wrist and neck. The window of their second-floor bedroom was open. She was conscious.

When Patrick asked where the kids were, Lindsay replied, "In the basement," according to Sprague.

There, Patrick found his three children with exercise bands still wrapped around each of their necks.

On Monday, Sprague said, Lindsay Clancy called her husband from her hospital bed and told him she killed their children "because she heard a voice and had 'a moment of psychosis,'" though Patrick told prosecutors his wife had never mentioned hearing voices.

"She planned these murders. She gave herself the time and privacy she needed to commit the murders, and then she strangled each child in the place where they should have felt the safest - at home with their mom," said Sprague.

RELATED | Mother accused of killing her 3 kids before attempting suicide, making progress in hospital

Clancy's defense attorney argued that the killings "were not planned by any means" and were a product of mental illness. He added that Clancy had previously mentioned having suicidal thoughts and checked herself into a mental health facility for five days in early January.

On Tuesday, a judge ordered Clancy to remain hospitalized until medically cleared to move to a rehabilitation facility. A probable cause hearing was scheduled for May 2.

The video in the player above is from a previous report.