Cuban is by far the most recognizable name among the bidders for the Cubs. He is a flamboyant billionaire who already owns an NBA team. But he also manages to still relate to the everyday fan. And some experts believe these charges may take him out of the running.
It was a low key night in the offseason for Cubs fans in Wrigleyville. But the news about Cuban was a big deal. The colorful owner of the Dallas Mavericks has been high profile in his bid to buy for the Cubs. He's been a frequent visitor to Wrigley Field and at Cubs players' events away from the park.
"He'd be a great owner for the Cubs, spends money, athletes, it's what we need," said Jason Waychoff, Cubs fan.
A number of web sites have even set up petitions urging the Cubs' current owner Sam Zell and Major League Baseball to let Cuban buy the team. But Monday's charges of insider trading might make that much less likely.
"Baseball owners strike me as a conservative group. I think Frank McCourt, when he bought the Dodgers, was about as out of the box as the group wants to get," said Damen Jackson, www.cubbienation.net.
"It would give Major League Baseball a better case to say, 'We're going to cote against including Mark Cuban as an owner,;" said Eldon Ham, Chicago Kent Law School.
The charges involve Cuban's sale of shares in a web search engine called Mamma.com. The Securities and Exchange Commission alleges he got confidential information the stock was about to drop and sold all his shares the day before it became public. It's similar to charges Martha Stewart faced.
Cuban released a statement on his web site Monday saying, "I am disappointed the commission chose to bring this case base upon its enforcement staff's win at any cost ambitions. The staff's process was result-oriented facts be damned. The government's claims are false and they will be proven to be so."
Regardless of the outcome, however, the timing is bad news for Cuban's efforts to buy the Cubs and for Zell's efforts to sell the team to the highest bidder.
"He needs to get a deal done to sell the Cubs because he needs the money from selling the team to pay off debt that he incurred when he acquired Tribune Company," said Joe Cahill, editor, Crain's Chicago Business.
The charges against Cuban are not criminal. They were filed by the SEC, and the most serious penalties he could face if found guilty would be fines, possibly in the neighborhood of $3 million. But fighting the charges will likely be a major distraction for him when the deadline for revised bids on the Cubs is said to be next week.
In a civil lawsuit filed in federal court in Dallas, the SEC alleged that in June 2004, Cuban was invited to get in on the coming stock offering by Mamma.com Inc. after he agreed to keep the information private.Cuban owned 6.3 percent of Mamma.com's stock at that time and was the largest known shareholder in the search engine company, according to the SEC. The agency said Cuban knew the shares would be sold below the current market price, and a few hours after receiving the information, he told his broker to sell all 600,000 shares before the public announcement of the offering. By selling when he did, Cuban avoided losses exceeding $750,000, the SEC said in its lawsuit. On June 30, the first trading day after the announcement, Mamma.com shares opened at $11.89, down 9.3 percent from the previous day's close of $13.10. Cuban, 50 and a multibillionaire, is a tech entrepreneur who sold his Broadcast.com to Yahoo Inc. in 1999 at the height of the dot-com boom. He bought the Mavericks in 2000 and spent heavily to improve the roster. He is the best known figure to be accused by the SEC of illegal insider trading since its case against Martha Stewart in 2002 for allegedly using advance knowledge of negative news for a company to sell her shares and avoid $45,673 in losses. The homemaking diva paid about $195,000 and agreed not to serve as the director of a public company for five years under a 2006 settlement with the SEC. Cuban's fury over referee calls on the basketball court is legendary, and his verbal outbursts at referees, National Basketball Association officials and sports reporters have raised his profile. He has been fined more than $1 million by the league for a series of episodes dating back to 2000 and suspended from a few games. "It is fundamentally unfair for someone to use access to nonpublic information to improperly gain an edge on the market," Scott Friestad, the SEC's deputy enforcement director, said in a statement. The agency alleged that Cuban acted with "scienter," a legal term indicating knowledge of wrongdoing. The SEC is seeking a court judgment against Cuban finding that he violated the antifraud provisions of the federal securities laws, an injunction against future violations, an unspecified civil penalty and restitution of the losses Cuban allegedly avoided. While the stock offering in question occurred more than four years ago, the SEC didn't learn about the specifics of the case until early 2007, according to agency attorneys. Cuban's lawyer said in a statement that the SEC's case "has no merit and is a product of gross abuse of prosecutorial discretion." "Mr. Cuban intends to contest the allegations and to demonstrate that the (SEC's) claims are infected by the misconduct of the staff of its enforcement division," Ralph Ferrara wrote in a note posted on Cuban's blog. In a twist, SEC Chairman Christopher Cox refrained from the commissioners' vote authorizing the enforcement action against Cuban. That was done in light of allegations by Cuban's attorneys that an SEC lawyer in the agency's Fort Worth office had copied Cox on an e-mail to Cuban in which he made a personal attack against him for his liberal political views. The SEC lawyer played no role in the investigation of the case and the matter was referred for possible disciplinary action against him, the agency said Monday. It said that Cox recused himself from the vote "to avoid any potential appearance" of conflict of interest. Maureen Coyle, an NBA spokeswoman, said the league does not comment on such matters. Cuban is one of the richest people in the world, according to Forbes magazine, which pegged his net worth at $2.3 billion as of March 2007. Besides the Mavericks, he owns Landmark Theaters, a large national chain dedicated to independent films, and the HDNet cable television channel. Cuban also runs a Web site called Sharesleuth.com, which bills itself as providing "independent Web-based reporting aimed at exposing securities fraud and corporate chicanery." An announcement on the site says there are plans for a companion, BailoutSleuth.com, to track the government's $700 billion financial rescue plan. Montreal-based Mamma.com decided in the spring of 2004 to raise capital in a so-called private placement in public equity offering, known as a PIPE, according to the SEC suit. In late June, as the PIPE moved toward closing, Mamma.com's investment bank suggested the company invite Cuban to participate. Because PIPEs often are sold at discounts to the stock's market price, the investment bank likely suggested that Mamma.com reach out to Cuban as the largest investor to help boost the offering. A bank salesman told Cuban the shares would be sold at a discount and that the offering included other incentives for investors, the SEC said. On June 28, Mamma.com Chief Executive Guy Faure e-mailed Cuban asking him to call him "ASAP," the SEC said. Cuban called four minutes later from the American Airlines Center in Dallas, home of the Mavericks, and spoke to Faure for about eight minutes. Faure, who resigned last year, began the conversation by telling Cuban he was about to give him confidential information. Cuban agreed to keep it to himself, the SEC said. Cuban became upset and angry during the conversation, and said that he didn't like PIPEs because they dilute the value of company stock for existing shareholders, according to the SEC. At the end of the call, Cuban said, "Well now I'm screwed. I can't sell." Mamma.com changed its name to Copernic Inc. in June 2007. Copernic officials did not return calls for comment Monday.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.