To his accusers, dash-cam video scenes taken from inside Officer Richard Fiorito's own squad car made it an open and shut case. In his police report, Fiorito wrote that one driver was swerving and nearly hitting parked cars. Attorneys representing nearly 40 people who say Fiorito trumped up charges against them say it shows exactly the opposite.
But on Monday night, Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez's office has ended its criminal investigation and has decided that no charges will be charged against Officer Fiorito.
"Based upon that investigation, it was determined that there were a number of inconsistencies. A number of the witnesses had severe credibility issues. And it was ultimately determined we wouldn't be able to meet our burden which in a criminal case is beyond a reasonable doubt," said Dan Kirk, Alvarez' chief of staff.
In early October, the Chicago Police Department placed Fiorito on administrative leave after ABC7 news aired dash-cam video that seemed to show inconsistencies in his written police reports.
But the state's attorney's office says many of the alleged victims were not credible after reviewing their testimony in different hearings.
"Individual witnesses' testimony differed in ways that can't be explained between different hearings and that is all I can really say about it," said Kirk.
"Here we are on the eve of the primary election and this is when they dump the bad news, so this was entirely predictable," said Andy Thayer, co-founder, Gay Liberation Network. Thayer, an activist leading the charge against Fiorito, says the decision from Alvarez isn't surprising.
"I'd say it's a shock. A punch in the gut," said Mary Cay Marubio, defense attorney.
The federal civil suit against Fiorito will continue on. And the Chicago Police Department tells ABC7 that Fiorito will remain on desk duty until an Internal Affairs investigation has been completed.
ABC7 was unable to reach Fiorito or his attorney for comment.
In response to the charge that Anita Alvarez is only protecting one of her own, her chief of staff points out that five Chicago police officers have been charged with felonies within the past year.