Two men, both 41, were shot just before 2:20 p.m., one fatally, according to the Gary Police Department.
The Lake County, Indiana Coroner's Office said Degerie Scott, 41, of Gary died just after 2:45 p.m. Saturday.
Several cars were left riddled with bullet holes in the parking lot outside St. Monica and Luke Church, in the 600-block of Rhode Island Street.
The wounded victim, also from Gary, had stabilized, police said.
RELATED: Villa Park shooting at indoor amusement center leaves 1 hurt; suspect caught in Chicago, police say
In a news release, the Diocese of Gary said family had received permission to rent the church's parish hall for a repast following a burial of a family member.
The diocese confirms the family who rented the hall were not parishioners.
"We pray for the family and their loved ones, may (they) be comforted as they begin to process this terrible tragedy," said Bishop Robert McClory.
Gary Mayor Jerome Prince offered his condolences, saying "It is beyond comprehension how anyone can attack a family already in mourning."
No one is in custody.
The video in the player above is from an earlier report.